Reason-Ugh!

(FB posting of mine):”Every time I have an inspiration these days, someone has a reason why it isn’t so or can’t be. Reason ,which at some point in history was an instrument of liberation ,has now become a means of enslavement! Because this is so important, I think I’m going to post this every day for awhile. Now, go ahead and tell me why that isn’t a good idea ! I dare you lol”

If one looks more deeply,you can see that, in fact, Reason is a bigger problem than all the other cardinal sins like greed,lust ,envy and pride put together! Why? Because reason is used to justify all the other sins!The psychoanalysts call that”Intellectualization” or “Rationnalization” and it is one of the major defense mechanisms of the ego.

So the greedy person says:”You need money to survive and you have to plan for your financial security.”Even more poignant it will say”the financial well-being of your family”! How can you resist that one.When Mike Tyson bit off part of the ear of his opponent during a fight with Evander Hollyfield,he was asked why he did it”I have to feed my family” he answered.Really! Admittedly there are more clever rationnalizers around but that was a particularly vivid example.Trump will say to the applause of his audience;”Put America first” which is a thinly-covered veil for American greed-on a personal and collective level.Not even the Democrats will challenge him on that policy! After all, we need to be greedy as a nation,no?

Pride will say”But I deserved that.Look how clever I am or look how hard I worked for that”Lust will say: “But women are beautiful: aren’t they the creation of our Lord”? Can you begin to see how sinister this all is.We could go down the list of all the major sins but I think by now the reader is getting the point.Watch it play out all around you in your lives.There’s plenty of it,I guarantee you.

I don’t know about your situation but I am surrounded by this contagion on a daily basis-dealing with government offices and large private institutions,dealing with friends and relatives,going to the market,even.But there are islands of sanity in this sea of obscurity-so there is hope-I think-but not much.

In was initially introduced to this problem at a series of Est Seminars in the 1970’s.The trainer was at the board writing down the stages of spiritual development. In his c;lassification, Reason was the lowest level-just barely above animality! He repeated the phrase several times:”Reason is the lowest level of spiritual development.”It registered in a deep place in m,y being. But if you look around you- at the Justice System,Government Administration,Universities(don’t get me started on them) you will see that it has the most credibility and the most investment.Look how much money is now invested in University education and how much money is invested in building churches and synagogues and mosques.Yes,the Intellect has taken over the role of Temple and faith.

After my foray into Est seminars , I began studying the Vedanta .Aha! These people understood that the mind was a repository of illusion.Is anyone putting that age-old insight into use in contemporary society?No,not even in India! Then there were the Zen Buddhists also trying to escape from the tyranny of the mind.They talk about”Seeing” and “Hearing” an d “Feeling.”(Btw Interesting parallel with the Quran where Allah talks about the people who are blind and deaf and have hardened hearts.It could easily have been talking about the administrators and intellectuals of contemporary society but at the time it was referring to the unbelievers.There are still a few of those around,I believe lol)

And what about the Sufis.Here is a poem by Jellalludin Rumi:

Behind a blood-stained curtain,
Love has spread its gardens.
Lovers are busy with the beauty of the Love
that is beyond explanation.
Intellect says: The six directions are the limit,
there is nothing beyond them.
Love says: There is a road, and I have journeyed on it many times;
Love has detected markets beyond that market.
Intellect says: Do not set foot on the land of annihilation;
there is nothing there but thorns.
Love says: Those thorns you feel are only inside you!
Be silent!
Remove the thorn of existence from the foot of the heart;
so that you may see the gardens within.
Mashallah! And Sheikh Nazim used to warn us about “mind-productions”i.e. most of what you hear in everyday discussions.However many Islamic scholars and even Sufis are caught up with the obsession around reasonableness.I will leave the examples for now.
What I have just mentioned comes from the spiritual domain s.But what about science and psychology? That should be more acceptable,more credible,no?Not really.Freud began developing his ideas in the early 20th century.That’s more than a hundred years ago! He was an acknowledged genius and a great contributor to our “culture”(said with a French accent),no?Now one of his most ground-breaking and revolutionary ideas was the unconscious-more precisely that it is not our conscious mind,our rational thoughts, that are determining our behaviour-but rather the unconscious.You would think that beyond using that discovery in treating patients,society would want to use it in managing it’s affairs.Not at all.The entire discovery is shelved in favour of plodding on with rational procedures and regulations.
Then.of course we get a Trump and all the journalists are scurrying  to find the DSM classification of mental disorders, to explain his behaviour.But even then rarely do they look for the unconscious underpinnings of that behaviour.They are satisfied with the diagnosis-Narcissistic Personality Disorder, which allows them to denounce him even more vigorously!
Is there, then,anything to be done?On an institutional level,I would say a resounding”no”.However, on an individual level, we can begin working on our intuition,on our inner sight and hearing,on the sensitivity of our hearts.All the religions and forms of spirituality have methods for that.After that, we can hope for a snow-ball effect.You could call that bottom-up politics but it’s the only way to go.Happy Trails to you all.Salaams,Ibrahim

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *